{ "case_origin": "Synthetische Entwicklungsfälle aus dem modellgenerierten Testbeispiel; gezielte Änderungen durch Codex zur diagnostischen Sichtung. Keine unabhängigen Sollurteile, keine Expertenvalidierung, keine Golden- oder Held-out-Fälle.", "cases": [ { "case_id": "baseline", "changes_from_baseline": [], "input": { "farm": { "region": { "bentazon_reauthorized": false, "federal_state": "Burgenland", "is_eastern_lower_austria_or_tullnerfeld": false }, "year": 2026 }, "land": { "groundwater_arable_area_ha": 5.03, "parcels": [ { "cover_crop_planted_by_11_15": false, "crop_area_ha": 0.2, "crop_category": "cereal", "field_record_complete": true, "following_crop_planted_by_11_15": true, "following_crop_reduction_kg_per_ha": 0, "id": "p1", "in_groundwater_area": true, "kg_number": "32001", "nitrogen_surplus_kg_per_ha": 0, "psm_active_ingredients": [] } ], "total_arable_area_ha": 10 }, "measure": { "first_participation_year": 2024, "participates_cover_evergreen": false, "participates_cover_intercrop": true, "participates_organic": false, "requested": true }, "options": { "cultan": { "external_equipment": false, "has_ammonium_depot_injection": false, "requested": false }, "psm_avoidance_surcharge": { "requested": false }, "strong_n_reduced_pig_feeding": { "also_claimed_in_liquid_manure_measure": false, "feed_categories": [], "requested": false }, "vienna_humus": { "recognized_carbon_project_confirmation": false, "requested": false, "turning_tillage_other_than_after_maize": false }, "washout_risk": { "parcel_ids": [], "requested": false } }, "records": { "cultan_external_service_evidence": true, "cultan_field_records_complete": true, "education_completed_date": "2026-12-31", "education_hours": 10, "education_provider_recognized": true, "farm_balance_completed_by_next_01_31": true, "farm_planning_completed_by_02_28": true, "oo_ipm_inspection_or_warning_documented": true, "pig_feed_recipe_evidence": true, "soil_samples": [ { "draw_date": "2024-01-01", "lab_accredited": true }, { "draw_date": "2025-01-01", "lab_accredited": true } ], "vienna_extra_education_hours": 0, "water_protection_concept_complete": true } }, "input_sha256": "ac3e81962fb4def9ce72adca7eaf440cc439c244bddf09b07846a2d97334cbcc", "opa_result": { "result": [ { "expressions": [ { "location": { "col": 1, "row": 1 }, "text": "data.oepul.o6_16.decision", "value": { "annex_g_catalog_matches": 1, "eligible": true, "nitrogen_reduction_factor": 0.8, "premium_components_from_2024": [ { "component": "base", "eur_per_ha": 54.0 }, { "component": "education_first_10_ha", "eur_per_ha": 60.0 } ], "required_soil_samples": 2, "violations": [] } } ] } ] }, "output": { "annex_g_catalog_matches": 1, "eligible": true, "nitrogen_reduction_factor": 0.8, "premium_components_from_2024": [ { "component": "base", "eur_per_ha": 54.0 }, { "component": "education_first_10_ha", "eur_per_ha": 60.0 } ], "required_soil_samples": 2, "violations": [] }, "output_changed_from_baseline": false, "purpose": "Synthetische Ausgangskonstellation zur Beobachtung der nativen Ausgabe; kein fachlich bestätigter Positivfall.", "status": "defined" }, { "case_id": "variation", "changes_from_baseline": [ { "after": { "present": true, "value": 9 }, "before": { "present": true, "value": 10 }, "path": "/records/education_hours" } ], "input": { "farm": { "region": { "bentazon_reauthorized": false, "federal_state": "Burgenland", "is_eastern_lower_austria_or_tullnerfeld": false }, "year": 2026 }, "land": { "groundwater_arable_area_ha": 5.03, "parcels": [ { "cover_crop_planted_by_11_15": false, "crop_area_ha": 0.2, "crop_category": "cereal", "field_record_complete": true, "following_crop_planted_by_11_15": true, "following_crop_reduction_kg_per_ha": 0, "id": "p1", "in_groundwater_area": true, "kg_number": "32001", "nitrogen_surplus_kg_per_ha": 0, "psm_active_ingredients": [] } ], "total_arable_area_ha": 10 }, "measure": { "first_participation_year": 2024, "participates_cover_evergreen": false, "participates_cover_intercrop": true, "participates_organic": false, "requested": true }, "options": { "cultan": { "external_equipment": false, "has_ammonium_depot_injection": false, "requested": false }, "psm_avoidance_surcharge": { "requested": false }, "strong_n_reduced_pig_feeding": { "also_claimed_in_liquid_manure_measure": false, "feed_categories": [], "requested": false }, "vienna_humus": { "recognized_carbon_project_confirmation": false, "requested": false, "turning_tillage_other_than_after_maize": false }, "washout_risk": { "parcel_ids": [], "requested": false } }, "records": { "cultan_external_service_evidence": true, "cultan_field_records_complete": true, "education_completed_date": "2026-12-31", "education_hours": 9, "education_provider_recognized": true, "farm_balance_completed_by_next_01_31": true, "farm_planning_completed_by_02_28": true, "oo_ipm_inspection_or_warning_documented": true, "pig_feed_recipe_evidence": true, "soil_samples": [ { "draw_date": "2024-01-01", "lab_accredited": true }, { "draw_date": "2025-01-01", "lab_accredited": true } ], "vienna_extra_education_hours": 0, "water_protection_concept_complete": true } }, "input_sha256": "72e4e5bafab0d07ecf7c3dd77a3fefe48708e298a7c029590e42c491fc079f09", "opa_result": { "result": [ { "expressions": [ { "location": { "col": 1, "row": 1 }, "text": "data.oepul.o6_16.decision", "value": { "annex_g_catalog_matches": 1, "eligible": false, "nitrogen_reduction_factor": 0.8, "premium_components_from_2024": [ { "component": "base", "eur_per_ha": 54.0 }, { "component": "education_first_10_ha", "eur_per_ha": 60.0 } ], "required_soil_samples": 2, "violations": [ "ten_hours_training_required" ] } } ] } ] }, "output": { "annex_g_catalog_matches": 1, "eligible": false, "nitrogen_reduction_factor": 0.8, "premium_components_from_2024": [ { "component": "base", "eur_per_ha": 54.0 }, { "component": "education_first_10_ha", "eur_per_ha": 60.0 } ], "required_soil_samples": 2, "violations": [ "ten_hours_training_required" ] }, "output_changed_from_baseline": true, "purpose": "education_hours von 10 auf 9 ändern; beobachten, ob die belegte Weiterbildungsgrenze einen eigenen Verletzungscode erzeugt.", "status": "defined" }, { "case_id": "missing_fact", "changes_from_baseline": [ { "after": { "present": false }, "before": { "present": true, "value": 10 }, "path": "/records/education_hours" } ], "input": { "farm": { "region": { "bentazon_reauthorized": false, "federal_state": "Burgenland", "is_eastern_lower_austria_or_tullnerfeld": false }, "year": 2026 }, "land": { "groundwater_arable_area_ha": 5.03, "parcels": [ { "cover_crop_planted_by_11_15": false, "crop_area_ha": 0.2, "crop_category": "cereal", "field_record_complete": true, "following_crop_planted_by_11_15": true, "following_crop_reduction_kg_per_ha": 0, "id": "p1", "in_groundwater_area": true, "kg_number": "32001", "nitrogen_surplus_kg_per_ha": 0, "psm_active_ingredients": [] } ], "total_arable_area_ha": 10 }, "measure": { "first_participation_year": 2024, "participates_cover_evergreen": false, "participates_cover_intercrop": true, "participates_organic": false, "requested": true }, "options": { "cultan": { "external_equipment": false, "has_ammonium_depot_injection": false, "requested": false }, "psm_avoidance_surcharge": { "requested": false }, "strong_n_reduced_pig_feeding": { "also_claimed_in_liquid_manure_measure": false, "feed_categories": [], "requested": false }, "vienna_humus": { "recognized_carbon_project_confirmation": false, "requested": false, "turning_tillage_other_than_after_maize": false }, "washout_risk": { "parcel_ids": [], "requested": false } }, "records": { "cultan_external_service_evidence": true, "cultan_field_records_complete": true, "education_completed_date": "2026-12-31", "education_provider_recognized": true, "farm_balance_completed_by_next_01_31": true, "farm_planning_completed_by_02_28": true, "oo_ipm_inspection_or_warning_documented": true, "pig_feed_recipe_evidence": true, "soil_samples": [ { "draw_date": "2024-01-01", "lab_accredited": true }, { "draw_date": "2025-01-01", "lab_accredited": true } ], "vienna_extra_education_hours": 0, "water_protection_concept_complete": true } }, "input_sha256": "0e89ef3bb440bd6fe4cadded674f396567ec7d88e98e6ce6844fe88f5b796430", "opa_result": { "result": [ { "expressions": [ { "location": { "col": 1, "row": 1 }, "text": "data.oepul.o6_16.decision", "value": { "annex_g_catalog_matches": 1, "eligible": true, "nitrogen_reduction_factor": 0.8, "premium_components_from_2024": [ { "component": "base", "eur_per_ha": 54.0 }, { "component": "education_first_10_ha", "eur_per_ha": 60.0 } ], "required_soil_samples": 2, "violations": [] } } ] } ] }, "output": { "annex_g_catalog_matches": 1, "eligible": true, "nitrogen_reduction_factor": 0.8, "premium_components_from_2024": [ { "component": "base", "eur_per_ha": 54.0 }, { "component": "education_first_10_ha", "eur_per_ha": 60.0 } ], "required_soil_samples": 2, "violations": [] }, "output_changed_from_baseline": false, "purpose": "education_hours entfernen; prüfen, ob ein fehlender Stundennachweis anders als neun belegte Stunden behandelt wird.", "status": "defined" } ], "compile": { "errors": [], "status": "compiled" }, "input_contract_note": "Native measure-/records-/options-Eingaben sowie land.parcels; Acker-/Gebietsflächen in ha, N-Überschuss und Folgekulturreduktion in kg N/ha, Weiterbildung in Stunden, Probennahme als ISO-Datum. Der Gebietsflag und kg_number sind synthetische, aus dem Modelltest übernommene Nachweise, keine GIS-Verifikation.", "inventory": { "independent_reference_case_status": "not_adjudicated", "profile_proposal_count": 57, "rule_count": 71, "rule_type_counts": { "annual_option_period": 1, "application": 2, "autumn_establishment": 1, "calculation": 7, "coding": 1, "combination": 1, "combination_requirement": 1, "compatibility": 4, "contract_period": 1, "cultan": 2, "deadline": 2, "drought_exception": 2, "exception": 2, "general": 5, "minimum_area": 2, "nitrogen_balance": 2, "notice": 2, "option_minimum": 1, "pig_access": 1, "pig_feed": 3, "plant_protection": 2, "premium": 3, "recording": 2, "sanction": 1, "scope": 1, "soil_testing": 3, "training": 5, "upper_austria": 4, "vienna_option": 3, "washout": 4 }, "source_count": 8, "source_coverage_claims": [ { "disposition_counts": { "not_rule": 2, "rules": 12 }, "item_count": 14, "review_scope": "full_document", "source_id": "measure_sheet" }, { "disposition_counts": { "not_rule": 1, "rules": 8 }, "item_count": 9, "review_scope": "full_document", "source_id": "general_conditions" }, { "disposition_counts": { "rules": 4 }, "item_count": 4, "review_scope": "targeted_sections", "source_id": "legal_measure_and_annexes" }, { "disposition_counts": { "rules": 4 }, "item_count": 4, "review_scope": "targeted_sections", "source_id": "legal_annexes" }, { "disposition_counts": { "rules": 1 }, "item_count": 1, "review_scope": "full_document", "source_id": "notice_may_2026" }, { "disposition_counts": { "rules": 1 }, "item_count": 1, "review_scope": "full_document", "source_id": "notice_june_2026" }, { "disposition_counts": { "not_rule": 1, "rules": 1 }, "item_count": 2, "review_scope": "full_document", "source_id": "notice_august_05_2026" }, { "disposition_counts": { "not_rule": 1, "rules": 1 }, "item_count": 2, "review_scope": "full_document", "source_id": "notice_august_12_2026" } ], "static_policy_input_paths": [ "input.farm.bentazon_reauthorized", "input.farm.region.federal_state", "input.farm.region.is_eastern_lower_austria_or_tullnerfeld", "input.farm.year", "input.land.groundwater_arable_area_ha", "input.land.parcels", "input.land.total_arable_area_ha", "input.livestock.pig_gve_average", "input.measure.first_participation_year", "input.measure.oo_chemical_psm_application", "input.measure.oo_variant_3_cover", "input.measure.participates_cover_evergreen", "input.measure.participates_cover_intercrop", "input.measure.participates_organic", "input.measure.requested", "input.options.cultan.external_equipment", "input.options.cultan.has_ammonium_depot_injection", "input.options.cultan.requested", "input.options.psm_avoidance_surcharge.requested", "input.options.strong_n_reduced_pig_feeding.also_claimed_in_liquid_manure_measure", "input.options.strong_n_reduced_pig_feeding.feed_categories", "input.options.strong_n_reduced_pig_feeding.requested", "input.options.vienna_humus.recognized_carbon_project_confirmation", "input.options.vienna_humus.requested", "input.options.vienna_humus.turning_tillage_other_than_after_maize", "input.options.washout_risk.parcel_ids", "input.options.washout_risk.requested", "input.records.cultan_external_service_evidence", "input.records.cultan_field_records_complete", "input.records.education_completed_date", "input.records.education_hours", "input.records.education_provider_recognized", "input.records.farm_balance_completed_by_next_01_31", "input.records.farm_planning_completed_by_02_28", "input.records.oo_ipm_inspection_or_warning_documented", "input.records.pig_feed_recipe_evidence", "input.records.soil_samples", "input.records.vienna_extra_education_hours", "input.records.water_protection_concept_complete" ] }, "measure_id": "o6_16", "open_dependencies": [ "Historischer Luna-Quellenstand bleibt unverändert; Übereinstimmung mit dem aktuellen Quellenpaket und verbindliche Gesamtauslegung sind vor einer produktiven Übernahme separat zu prüfen.", "Native Eingaben sind kein gemeinsamer App-Vertrag; Herkunft, Vollständigkeit und Bedeutung der entscheidungsrelevanten Nachweisfelder benötigen eine gesonderte Zuordnung.", "N-Berechnung und Dünge-Detailtabellen außerhalb des damaligen Quellenpakets sind laut Run-Annahmen offen; die Prüfung übernimmt N-Werte als Eingabe.", "Gebiets-/Katastralgemeindennachweis und historische Anhang-G-Liste sind vor einer aktuellen GIS-/Förderentscheidung abzugleichen.", "Beobachtet: education_hours=9 erzeugt ten_hours_training_required und eligible=false; Entfernen von education_hours liefert dagegen wieder eligible=true ohne Verletzung. Ein eigener Status für die fehlende entscheidungsrelevante Angabe fehlt." ], "output_contract_note": "decision enthält eligible, Verletzungscodes, Bodenprobenbedarf, Reduktionsfaktor und Prämienkomponenten. eligible folgt requested plus leerer Verletzungsmenge; fehlende numerische Felder können einen Vergleich undefiniert lassen, ohne einen Missing-Data-Code zu erzeugen. Das Ergebnis ist eine Teilprüfung des historischen Quellen-/Eingabestands.", "query": "data.oepul.o6_16.decision", "references": [ { "detail": "Belegt die Query, tatsächlich konsumierte Eingabefelder, Checks und Berechnungen; die Variations- und Entfernungsfälle ändern jeweils genau einen konsumierten Blattwert.", "path": "runs/v2-o6_16-luna-high-20261005/workspace/policy/o6_16.rego" }, { "detail": "Modellgenerierte synthetische Entwicklungsbeispiele und Grenzwerte; keine unabhängige Ground Truth.", "path": "runs/v2-o6_16-luna-high-20261005/workspace/tests/o6_16_test.rego" }, { "detail": "Dokumentiert historische Quellen-/Eingabeannahmen und offene Integrations-/Auslegungsfragen.", "path": "runs/v2-o6_16-luna-high-20261005/workspace/notes/assumptions.md" } ], "run_id": "v2-o6_16-luna-high-20261005" }