{
  "case_origin": "DEVELOPMENT ONLY: Nahezu direkte synthetische Wiederverwendung von valid_base_input und test_arable_diversification_rejects_excessive_grain in runs/v2-o6_1b-luna-high-20260930/workspace/tests/o6_1b_test.rego; Kontrollstellenname explizit als synthetischer Marker ersetzt. Keine Expertenlabels, kein Golden- oder Heldout-Test; keine erwarteten fachlichen Ergebnisse werden vergeben.",
  "cases": [
    {
      "case_id": "baseline",
      "changes_from_baseline": [],
      "input": {
        "certifications": {
          "organic": {
            "control_body": "synthetic_control_body",
            "is_certified": true
          }
        },
        "contract": {
          "end_date": "2028-12-31",
          "start_year": 2025
        },
        "first_participation_year": 2025,
        "land": {
          "arable_area_ha": 20,
          "arable_biodiversity_area_ha": 1.4,
          "arable_fields_with_more_than_5ha_are_valid": true,
          "grain_and_maize_share": 0.7,
          "grassland_biodiversity_area_ha": 1.4,
          "grassland_fields_with_more_than_5ha_are_valid": true,
          "max_crop_share": 0.5,
          "mowed_grassland_area_ha": 20,
          "protected_cultivation_area_ha": 0,
          "total_area_ha": 100
        },
        "livestock": {
          "conventional_equines_only": false,
          "has_livestock": false,
          "uncertified_chickens": 0,
          "uncertified_fattening_pigs": 0
        },
        "year": 2026
      },
      "input_sha256": "415f17507574f3b9379a796f3bfa5625f729e045be676abad8fa87794739cc10",
      "opa_result": {
        "result": [
          {
            "expressions": [
              {
                "location": {
                  "col": 1,
                  "row": 1
                },
                "text": "data.o6_1b.eligible",
                "value": true
              }
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "output": true,
      "output_changed_from_baseline": false,
      "purpose": "Konstruierte synthetische Basis zur Beobachtung des nativen Kandidaten; kein bestätigter Förderfall.",
      "status": "defined"
    },
    {
      "case_id": "variation",
      "changes_from_baseline": [
        {
          "after": {
            "present": true,
            "value": 0.76
          },
          "before": {
            "present": true,
            "value": 0.7
          },
          "path": "/land/grain_and_maize_share"
        }
      ],
      "input": {
        "certifications": {
          "organic": {
            "control_body": "synthetic_control_body",
            "is_certified": true
          }
        },
        "contract": {
          "end_date": "2028-12-31",
          "start_year": 2025
        },
        "first_participation_year": 2025,
        "land": {
          "arable_area_ha": 20,
          "arable_biodiversity_area_ha": 1.4,
          "arable_fields_with_more_than_5ha_are_valid": true,
          "grain_and_maize_share": 0.76,
          "grassland_biodiversity_area_ha": 1.4,
          "grassland_fields_with_more_than_5ha_are_valid": true,
          "max_crop_share": 0.5,
          "mowed_grassland_area_ha": 20,
          "protected_cultivation_area_ha": 0,
          "total_area_ha": 100
        },
        "livestock": {
          "conventional_equines_only": false,
          "has_livestock": false,
          "uncertified_chickens": 0,
          "uncertified_fattening_pigs": 0
        },
        "year": 2026
      },
      "input_sha256": "f2b4a374317ec89f4b0c1012783b6b88fc4e6b56ed19c1d96070b5812e94e845",
      "opa_result": {
        "result": [
          {
            "expressions": [
              {
                "location": {
                  "col": 1,
                  "row": 1
                },
                "text": "data.o6_1b.eligible",
                "value": false
              }
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "output": false,
      "output_changed_from_baseline": true,
      "purpose": "Nur land.grain_and_maize_share von 0,70 auf 0,76 ändern: native Grenze 0,75 überschreiten.",
      "status": "defined"
    },
    {
      "case_id": "missing_fact",
      "changes_from_baseline": [
        {
          "after": {
            "present": false
          },
          "before": {
            "present": true,
            "value": true
          },
          "path": "/certifications/organic/is_certified"
        }
      ],
      "input": {
        "certifications": {
          "organic": {
            "control_body": "synthetic_control_body"
          }
        },
        "contract": {
          "end_date": "2028-12-31",
          "start_year": 2025
        },
        "first_participation_year": 2025,
        "land": {
          "arable_area_ha": 20,
          "arable_biodiversity_area_ha": 1.4,
          "arable_fields_with_more_than_5ha_are_valid": true,
          "grain_and_maize_share": 0.7,
          "grassland_biodiversity_area_ha": 1.4,
          "grassland_fields_with_more_than_5ha_are_valid": true,
          "max_crop_share": 0.5,
          "mowed_grassland_area_ha": 20,
          "protected_cultivation_area_ha": 0,
          "total_area_ha": 100
        },
        "livestock": {
          "conventional_equines_only": false,
          "has_livestock": false,
          "uncertified_chickens": 0,
          "uncertified_fattening_pigs": 0
        },
        "year": 2026
      },
      "input_sha256": "fcb73bc7e69ab2842aa49dacb891de9c15ac55861f7498e51e57f77b3f87a41c",
      "opa_result": {
        "result": [
          {
            "expressions": [
              {
                "location": {
                  "col": 1,
                  "row": 1
                },
                "text": "data.o6_1b.eligible",
                "value": false
              }
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "output": false,
      "output_changed_from_baseline": true,
      "purpose": "Nur certifications.organic.is_certified entfernen: Beobachtung, wie ein fehlender Zertifizierungsfakt in den booleschen Ausgabevertrag fällt.",
      "status": "defined"
    }
  ],
  "compile": {
    "errors": [],
    "status": "compiled"
  },
  "input_contract_note": "Root-level year und first_participation_year, contract, certifications, aggregierte land-Fakten und livestock. Anteile sind Bruchteile 0–1. Feldstückkonformität wird als synthetisch vorausgesetzter boolescher Fakt eingegeben, nicht aus Einzelparzellen bewiesen. Alle Werte sind ausdrücklich synthetische Entwicklungsannahmen; die Eingaben repräsentieren keinen echten Betrieb.",
  "inventory": {
    "independent_reference_case_status": "not_adjudicated",
    "profile_proposal_count": 95,
    "rule_count": 43,
    "rule_type_counts": {
      "area_threshold": 4,
      "automatic_surcharge": 3,
      "biodiversity_management": 2,
      "choice": 1,
      "classification": 1,
      "combination": 1,
      "contract_duration": 1,
      "crop_diversification": 1,
      "deadline": 4,
      "duration": 1,
      "eligibility": 8,
      "exception": 4,
      "input_ban": 1,
      "optional_surcharge": 7,
      "premium": 2,
      "reporting": 1,
      "training": 1
    },
    "source_count": 8,
    "source_coverage_claims": [
      {
        "disposition_counts": {
          "not_rule": 2,
          "rules": 15
        },
        "item_count": 17,
        "review_scope": "full_document",
        "source_id": "o6_1b"
      },
      {
        "disposition_counts": {
          "not_rule": 2,
          "rules": 5
        },
        "item_count": 7,
        "review_scope": "full_document",
        "source_id": "o6_general"
      },
      {
        "disposition_counts": {
          "rules": 5
        },
        "item_count": 5,
        "review_scope": "targeted_sections",
        "source_id": "srl_oepul_2023"
      },
      {
        "disposition_counts": {
          "rules": 4
        },
        "item_count": 4,
        "review_scope": "targeted_sections",
        "source_id": "srl_oepul_2023_anhaenge"
      },
      {
        "disposition_counts": {
          "rules": 1
        },
        "item_count": 1,
        "review_scope": "full_document",
        "source_id": "notice_2026_05_22"
      },
      {
        "disposition_counts": {
          "not_rule": 1
        },
        "item_count": 1,
        "review_scope": "full_document",
        "source_id": "notice_2026_06_12"
      },
      {
        "disposition_counts": {
          "rules": 1
        },
        "item_count": 1,
        "review_scope": "full_document",
        "source_id": "notice_2026_08_05"
      },
      {
        "disposition_counts": {
          "rules": 1
        },
        "item_count": 1,
        "review_scope": "full_document",
        "source_id": "notice_2026_08_12"
      }
    ],
    "static_policy_input_paths": [
      "input.biodiversity.arable.exempt_from_new_sowing",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.fertilizer_used",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.insect_pollinated_partners",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.invasive_species_evidence",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.invasive_species_share",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.minimum_duration_years",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.non_insect_pollinated_share",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.plant_families",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.sown_date",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.unrestricted_share",
      "input.biodiversity.arable.use_date",
      "input.biodiversity.early_use_before_august",
      "input.biodiversity.grassland.annual_mowing_with_removal",
      "input.biodiversity.grassland.dormant_days",
      "input.biodiversity.grassland.fertilizer_only_manure_or_compost",
      "input.biodiversity.grassland.first_use_date",
      "input.biodiversity.grassland.last_use_date",
      "input.biodiversity.grassland.max_uses_per_year",
      "input.biodiversity.grassland.mowing_with_removal",
      "input.biodiversity.grassland.second_use_in_year",
      "input.biodiversity.grassland.variant",
      "input.biodiversity.regional_seed.ecotype_seed",
      "input.biodiversity.regional_seed.family_count",
      "input.biodiversity.regional_seed.kind",
      "input.biodiversity.regional_seed.max_single_species_share",
      "input.biodiversity.regional_seed.regional_origin_documented",
      "input.biodiversity.regional_seed.seed_rate_kg_ha",
      "input.biodiversity.regional_seed.sown_date",
      "input.biodiversity.regional_seed.species_count",
      "input.biodiversity.third_arable_use",
      "input.certifications.organic.control_body",
      "input.certifications.organic.is_certified",
      "input.contract.end_date",
      "input.contract.start_year",
      "input.crop.variety",
      "input.first_participation_year",
      "input.land.arable_area_ha",
      "input.land.arable_biodiversity_area_ha",
      "input.land.arable_fields_with_more_than_5ha_are_valid",
      "input.land.circular_arable_crop_is_eligible",
      "input.land.circular_arable_share",
      "input.land.circular_grassland_share",
      "input.land.grain_and_maize_share",
      "input.land.grassland_biodiversity_area_for_arable_ha",
      "input.land.grassland_biodiversity_area_ha",
      "input.land.grassland_fields_with_more_than_5ha_are_valid",
      "input.land.max_crop_share",
      "input.land.mowed_grassland_area_ha",
      "input.land.protected_cultivation_area_ha",
      "input.land.total_area_ha",
      "input.livestock.average_rgve_per_forage_ha",
      "input.livestock.biological_equines",
      "input.livestock.category",
      "input.livestock.conventional_equines_only",
      "input.livestock.has_livestock",
      "input.livestock.is_forage_eating_livestock_farm",
      "input.livestock.uncertified_chickens",
      "input.livestock.uncertified_fattening_pigs",
      "input.monitoring.data_submitted_annually",
      "input.monitoring.has_gl06_gl15_or_gl25",
      "input.monitoring.introductory_event_completed",
      "input.monitoring.nature_measure",
      "input.monitoring.participation_confirmation",
      "input.monitoring.program",
      "input.monitoring.ta01_on_at_least_one_parcel",
      "input.pheromone_traps.days_on_field",
      "input.pheromone_traps.emptyings_during_minimum_period",
      "input.pheromone_traps.is_sugar_beet_or_previous_sugar_beet_parcel",
      "input.pheromone_traps.records_complete",
      "input.pheromone_traps.traps_per_ha",
      "input.year"
    ]
  },
  "measure_id": "o6_1b",
  "open_dependencies": [
    "Boolesche Ausgabe erklärt weder betroffene Klausel noch fehlende Daten; für App-Anzeige ist ein gesonderter dokumentierter Diagnosevertrag nötig.",
    "Land-Feldstückkonformität ist nur behaupteter Input. Unabhängige Referenzprüfung und ausgewählte Fachfragen aus App #140 bleiben für eine semantische Bewertung offen.",
    "eligible deckt die separaten Bewirtschaftungs- und Variantenprüfungen nicht ab; true darf nicht als vollständige Förderfreigabe bezeichnet werden."
  ],
  "output_contract_note": "Der Kandidat besitzt kein natives decision/result-Objekt: eligible ist ein boolescher Wert ohne Gründe oder fehlende-Fakten-Liste. Er aggregiert neun Basisprüfungen; Bewirtschaftung, Monitoring, Fristen, Varianten und Prämien existieren als separate Helper und werden hier nicht zu einer vollständigen BIO-Entscheidung zusammengeführt.",
  "query": "data.o6_1b.eligible",
  "references": [
    {
      "detail": "Native Eingabepfade und ausdrücklich gewählter Ausgabepunkt; Änderung und fehlende Tatsache richten sich nach dem ausführbaren Kandidaten, nicht nach einer fachlichen Sollentscheidung.",
      "path": "runs/v2-o6_1b-luna-high-20260930/workspace/policy/o6_1b.rego"
    },
    {
      "detail": "Nahezu direkte synthetische Wiederverwendung von valid_base_input und test_arable_diversification_rejects_excessive_grain in runs/v2-o6_1b-luna-high-20260930/workspace/tests/o6_1b_test.rego; Kontrollstellenname explizit als synthetischer Marker ersetzt.",
      "path": "runs/v2-o6_1b-luna-high-20260930/workspace/tests/o6_1b_test.rego"
    },
    {
      "detail": "Historische Modellannahmen und offene Abgrenzungen; keine unabhängige Expertenbestätigung.",
      "path": "runs/v2-o6_1b-luna-high-20260930/workspace/notes/assumptions.md"
    },
    {
      "detail": "Katalog o6_1b_crop_diversification beschreibt die 0,75-/0,55-Anteilsgrenzen einschließlich Ausnahmen; die Variation prüft nur den Getreide-/Mais-Anteil des nativen Codes.",
      "path": "runs/v2-o6_1b-luna-high-20260930/workspace/rules/rules.json"
    }
  ],
  "run_id": "v2-o6_1b-luna-high-20260930"
}